Improve error messages

CHANGELOG.md

@@ -7,6 +7,7 @@
 * Added "EXPERIMENTAL!" label to two-way sync toggle in Rojo's Roblox Studio plugin.
 * Fixed `Name` and `Parent` properties being allowed in Rojo projects. ([#413][pr-413])
 * Fixed "Open Scripts Externally" feature crashing Studio ([#369][issue-369])
+* Improved error messages for misconfigured projects.
 
 [issue-369]: https://github.com/rojo-rbx/rojo/issues/369
 [pr-413]: https://github.com/rojo-rbx/rojo/pull/413

src/snapshot_middleware/project.rs

@@ -1,6 +1,6 @@
 use std::{borrow::Cow, collections::HashMap, path::Path};
 
-use anyhow::Context;
+use anyhow::{bail, Context};
 use memofs::Vfs;
 use rbx_reflection::ClassTag;
 
@@ -66,11 +66,13 @@ pub fn snapshot_project_node(
 ) -> SnapshotInstanceResult {
     let project_folder = project_path.parent().unwrap();
 
-    let name = Cow::Owned(instance_name.to_owned());
+    let class_name_from_project = node
-    let mut class_name = node
         .class_name
         .as_ref()
         .map(|name| Cow::Owned(name.clone()));
+    let mut class_name_from_path = None;
+
+    let name = Cow::Owned(instance_name.to_owned());
     let mut properties = HashMap::new();
     let mut children = Vec::new();
     let mut metadata = InstanceMetadata::default();
@@ -85,24 +87,7 @@ pub fn snapshot_project_node(
         };
 
         if let Some(snapshot) = snapshot_from_vfs(context, vfs, &path)? {
-            // If a class name was already specified, then it'll override the
+            class_name_from_path = Some(snapshot.class_name);
-            // class name of this snapshot ONLY if it's a Folder.
-            //
-            // This restriction is in place to prevent applying properties to
-            // instances that don't make sense. The primary use-case for using
-            // $className and $path at the same time is to use a directory as a
-            // service in a place file.
-            class_name = match class_name {
-                Some(class_name) => {
-                    if snapshot.class_name == "Folder" {
-                        Some(class_name)
-                    } else {
-                        // TODO: Turn this into an error object.
-                        panic!("If $className and $path are specified, $path must yield an instance of class Folder");
-                    }
-                }
-                None => Some(snapshot.class_name),
-            };
 
             // Properties from the snapshot are pulled in unchanged, and
             // overridden by properties set on the project node.
@@ -129,34 +114,66 @@ pub fn snapshot_project_node(
         }
     }
 
-    let class_name = class_name
+    let class_name_from_inference = infer_class_name(&name, parent_class);
-        .or_else(|| {
-            // If className wasn't defined from another source, we may be able
-            // to infer one.
 
-            let parent_class = parent_class?;
+    let class_name = match (
+        class_name_from_project,
+        class_name_from_path,
+        class_name_from_inference,
+    ) {
+        // These are the easy, happy paths!
+        (Some(project), None, None) => project,
+        (None, Some(path), None) => path,
+        (None, None, Some(inference)) => inference,
 
-            if parent_class == "DataModel" {
+        // If the user specifies a class name, but there's an inferred class
-                // Members of DataModel with names that match known services are
+        // name, we prefer the name listed explicitly by the user.
-                // probably supposed to be those services.
+        (Some(project), None, Some(_)) => project,
 
-                let descriptor = rbx_reflection_database::get().classes.get(&name)?;
+        // If the user has a $path pointing to a folder and we're able to infer
-
+        // a class name, let's use the inferred name. If the path we're pointing
-                if descriptor.tags.contains(&ClassTag::Service) {
+        // to isn't a folder, though, that's a user error.
-                    return Some(name.clone());
+        (None, Some(path), Some(inference)) => {
-                }
+            if path == "Folder" {
-            } else if parent_class == "StarterPlayer" {
+                inference
-                // StarterPlayer has two special members with their own classes.
+            } else {
-
+                path
-                if name == "StarterPlayerScripts" || name == "StarterCharacterScripts" {
-                    return Some(name.clone());
-                }
             }
+        }
 
-            None
+        (Some(project), Some(path), _) => {
-        })
+            if path == "Folder" {
-        // TODO: Turn this into an error object.
+                project
-        .expect("$className or $path must be specified");
+            } else {
+                bail!(
+                    "ClassName for Instance \"{}\" was specified in both the project file (as \"{}\") and from the filesystem (as \"{}\").\n\
+                     If $className and $path are both set, $path must refer to a Folder.
+                     \n\
+                     Project path: {}\n\
+                     Filesystem path: {}\n",
+                    instance_name,
+                    project,
+                    path,
+                    project_path.display(),
+                    node.path.as_ref().unwrap().display()
+                );
+            }
+        }
+
+        (None, None, None) => {
+            bail!(
+                "Instance \"{}\" is missing some required information.\n\
+                 One of the following must be true:\n\
+                 - $className must be set to the name of a Roblox class\n\
+                 - $path must be set to a path of an instance\n\
+                 - The instance must be a known service, like ReplicatedStorage\n\
+                 \n\
+                 Project path: {}",
+                instance_name,
+                project_path.display(),
+            );
+        }
+    };
 
     for (child_name, child_project_node) in &node.children {
         if let Some(child) = snapshot_project_node(
@@ -230,6 +247,32 @@ pub fn snapshot_project_node(
     }))
 }
 
+fn infer_class_name(name: &str, parent_class: Option<&str>) -> Option<Cow<'static, str>> {
+    // If className wasn't defined from another source, we may be able
+    // to infer one.
+
+    let parent_class = parent_class?;
+
+    if parent_class == "DataModel" {
+        // Members of DataModel with names that match known services are
+        // probably supposed to be those services.
+
+        let descriptor = rbx_reflection_database::get().classes.get(name)?;
+
+        if descriptor.tags.contains(&ClassTag::Service) {
+            return Some(Cow::Owned(name.to_owned()));
+        }
+    } else if parent_class == "StarterPlayer" {
+        // StarterPlayer has two special members with their own classes.
+
+        if name == "StarterPlayerScripts" || name == "StarterCharacterScripts" {
+            return Some(Cow::Owned(name.to_owned()));
+        }
+    }
+
+    None
+}
+
 // #[cfg(feature = "broken-tests")]
 #[cfg(test)]
 mod test {

test-projects/bad_classname_path_conflict/default.project.json

@@ -0,0 +1,7 @@
+{
+  "name": "bad_classname_path_conflict",
+  "tree": {
+    "$className": "DataModel",
+    "$path": "foo.txt"
+  }
+}

test-projects/bad_no_classname/default.project.json

@@ -0,0 +1,4 @@
+{
+  "name": "bad_no_classname",
+  "tree": {}
+}